FANDOM


  • Hello, what's wrong with comparing with Geass? In my opinion, they are similar enough to pay attention to it. I will not start war edits, I was just wondering.

      Loading editor
    • that is just your opinion right? can't put opinion on the page. If you got the source where that info comparing with Geass come from, please tell me where.

        Loading editor
    • The thing is, there are many things shared amongs anime from character designs/personalities/techniques, to plot points, enviroments, settings, etc. To add such things to a trivia would mean to include all other similarities spread amongst fictions.

      Trivia should be better used to compare from the sources that fictions are based on i.e. Real life events, religion, namesakes etc, since it is more direct and actual, wheras  comparing similarities to other works of fictions is more coindicential. Like the messages tend to say at the end of movies "the events of this creation are based soly in fiction. Any similarities to persons, events or locations are purly coincidental."

      Unless the creators themselves can be quoted saying the similarities between other works are intentional, then it really doesn't suit being placed in trivia, otherwise we'd have to add all similarities to all other fictions for everylittle thing. Best to stop it before it gets out of hand.

        Loading editor
    • Macho44 wrote:
      that is just your opinion right? can't put opinion on the page. If you got the source where that info comparing with Geass come from, please tell me where.

      My paragraph was added as an my opinion and not "obvious" fact. At the same time, as far as I know, Masaki really created under the influence of Suzuraku, not to mention the fact that they look almost like twin brothers. But of course, if it's so important, I will refrain from adding comparisons, although on Miyuki's page quietly hanging indent on her "possible" creation under the influence of Hindu goddess.


      P.S I apologize in advance for my poor English

        Loading editor
    • @ShibaBrother 

      I kinda agree when watching anime, Masaki really look like Suzuraku and Tatsuya look like Lelouch muscle version. But that is just my opinion and cant add to the page although as Travia. No problem, just don't do it next time.

        Loading editor
    • I personal think the problem is also that the chance someone reading / watching Mahouka know about the Hinduism religion is by far greater then know a specific other anime. Also because fictional stories go way back I'm sure we could find countless other stories where a char is similar to a char in Mahouka.

        Loading editor
    • Adauli wrote:
      I personal think the problem is also that the chance someone reading / watching Mahouka know about the Hinduism religion is by far greater then know a specific other anime. Also because fictional stories go way back I'm sure we could find countless other stories where a char is similar to a char in Mahouka.

      You understand me a little wrong. I easily believe that Miyuki is based on the Hindu goddess, the more Tatsuya is based on Shiva. Just seems a little unfair to me that there is also stated "it is possible". I just think a little bit unfair that there is also written "possible". But, it does not matter.

        Loading editor
    • @Macho44 

      Thank you for understanding. Well, I refrain from such additions, if I can not find the official sources about of this.

        Loading editor
    • By the way, I have a little question: Is it too "personal opinion"? It is obvious that at the moment Masaki has not the slightest chance, but according to the laws of romance, he is its only potential interest except her brother, because he is the only character who is fighting for her attention. Of course, it also does not principle, but then half of this wiki if desired can be called a "personal opinion," if only we are not talking about a dry retelling of events

        Loading editor
    • Masaki is official allowed to court Miyuki (even if Miyuki wished to deny it right away) so I don't see it as problem.

        Loading editor
    • Adauli wrote:
      Masaki is official allowed to court Miyuki (even if Miyuki wished to deny it right away) so I don't see it as problem.

      So, I can cancel the editing? Or is it easier to leave everything as is?

        Loading editor
    • You should put that in relationship page, not trivia. Also 

      " However, it seems the guy has no chance. " That's early to say that, Masaki has slightest chance but not that high. Better don't put that in the page.

        Loading editor
    • @Macho44 

      Thank you for the clarification. Well, personally, I wrote on the forum that Masaki can win her heart If the author decides to use certain tropes (especially given the forcible nature of Shiba's engagement), but I was immediately attacked by fans Maya's engagement, lol.

        Loading editor
    • Yeah. Mahouka has the biggest shipper comunity. Don't say or put in the page like Mayumi win or Honoka lose. They will gonna kill you.

        Loading editor
    • Macho44 wrote:
      Yeah. Mahouka has biggest shipper comunity. Don't say or put in the page like Mayumi win or Honoka lose. They will gonna kill you.

      I have already convinced in it: D Well, I would support Miyuki on full 100% if after 16th volume, she does not become so obsessed and annoying, so, I even began to wonder whether there is any chance at Mayumi or Masaki. Well, thanks again for your help, I will wait for the 21st volume, I hope there the story is somehow significantly advance after the dead 20th.

        Loading editor
    • i am an indian and i dont think that relationship between miyuki and tatsuya is like parvati and shiv.

      also shiva is the most powerful even than parvati,and is unstoppable if he opens his third eye

      while in novel miyuki is equal or more powerful than tatsuya

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message

Ad blocker interference detected!


Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.